Utica Insurance is a national insurer that offers several different types of policies to both commercial and personal customers throughout the country. The company was formed in 1916 and has its corporate headquarters in New Hartford, New York (with several satellite/regional offices in different regions across the United States). Click the office locator link on this page to find an office in your area. If you’re a current policyholder you can access your policy online (view details, make payments, request changes, etc.) by clicking the “Login” button on this page.