Stillwater Insurance Group is national insurance carrier that is licensed to operate in all 50 states. Stillwater’s main product lines are home, auto, renters, business, and umbrella policies. The company was founded in 2000 (initially known as Fidelity National Property/Casualty), and maintains office locations in Jacksonville (FL), Omaha (NE), and Santa Barbara (CA). Get a free property quote online by clicking the quote link on this page. Current policyholders can learn how to make payments, report claims, and more by going to the “Login” page.